Skip to main content

Open Record archive

  1. The Bill for the War Comes Due at the Checkout Counter
  2. A State Spends Its Force Abroad and Its Patience at Home
  3. The Security State Turns Its Tools Inward
  4. The Iran War Keeps Exporting Its Costs
  5. Power Turns on Its Witnesses
  6. A Government That Performs Power
  7. Firing Squad Meant to Be Watched
  8. The War Is Now the Economy
  9. War Abroad Party at Home
  10. Guardrails Left a Map
  11. Who Decides Who Pays
  12. Pressure Campaign Reaches Brazil
  13. Record Caught Up
  14. Machinery Pointed Inward
  15. Bond Market Prices the Deficit
  16. Three Ways an Argument Disappears
  17. The Machinery Keeps Running
  18. The War Is Now a Domestic Story
  19. Who Counts Not Who Votes
  20. No to a Map Yes to a Database
  21. Power Was Visible Accountability Was Not
  22. Records Landed Claims Did Not Hold
  23. Projected Power Argument at Home
  24. Washington Is Rationing What the Public Sees
  25. Who Gets to See What Power Is Doing
  26. Power Moves in Days
  27. Four Institutions Four Judges
  28. The Loud Fight Ends
  29. The Bill Came Due
  30. Six Institutions Said No
  31. Saying Stop Is Not Stopping
  32. AI Slowdown Accountability Gap
  33. Cost Arriving Channel Narrowing
  34. The Question Is Who Pays
  35. Washington Offers a Check
  36. Dividend Promise Failing Election Machinery
  37. War Automated Faster Than Accounted For
  38. Nineteen Months
  39. The Election Is Now a Docket
  40. The Rule Is Not the Safeguard
  41. The Price Walked Into an Election
  42. Outrunning Review
  43. Machinery of Who Counts
  44. War's Real Bill Arrives Far From the Gulf
  45. The Legal Justification Comes Last
  46. A Price, Not a Front
  47. The Price of a War Nobody Calls a War
  48. War's Second Front Is Economic
  49. Three Instruments, One Method
  50. Fight Over the Machinery
  51. Documents Caught Up With Statements
  52. Capacity Without Checks
  53. The Machinery Is Not Failing
  54. Coercion Is the Policy
  55. You Cannot Sue a Bond Market
  56. War Washington Cannot End
  57. Blockade and Bond Market
  58. The Bill Comes Due
  59. Money Lost, Surveillance Won
  60. Government Stopped Showing Its Work
  61. Routed Around, Not Repealed
  62. Enforcement Turned Inward
  63. Past the Point It Can Hold
  64. What It Cost to Lose
  65. Who Holds the Veto
  66. Risk Moves Down
  67. The Government Rents Its Surveillance
  68. The Powers Expand, the Checks Sit Empty
  69. The Promise Was Only Worth the Pressure Behind It
  70. The Senate Traded Away Its Leverage
  71. Two Orders and a Shrinking Stockpile
  72. What Money Bought
  73. Money Lost Michigan, Won Missouri
  74. Change the Accounting
  75. Two Clocks
  76. Who Decides What Counts as a Threat
  77. The Claim Arrives First

Publication sections

The Open RecordInvestigationsCommentaryMethodAbout

Publication utilities

CorrectionsRSS 2.0

In the thread The Academic Circle

Chomsky at Zorro

On March 20, 2015, Epstein's staff picked up Noam Chomsky and his wife Valeria from a Santa Fe spa and drove them to Zorro Ranch. The next day, Epstein's personal pilot flew Chomsky out toward a Monday Harvard commitment. The logistics were coordinated by physicist Lawrence Krauss and sit in three indexed emails in the 2025 DOJ release.

Aerial view of the Zorro Ranch mansion and surrounding desert, New Mexico, from the DOJ Epstein release. No people visible per file description.
The main house at Zorro Ranch in New Mexico, in an aerial photograph from the Justice Department's release.Photo: U.S. Department of Justice (EFTA00028566), public domain, via Wikimedia Commons
Documents
3
documents
Citations
19
citations
People
3
people
Pages of record
10
pages of record
Reading time
5
minutes to read
Source discipline

16 primary, 3 corroborating, 0 tertiary. 19 citations in all.

  • T1 Primary
  • T2 Corroborating
  • T3 Tertiary
People in this piece
  • Noam Chomsky, Adjacent
  • Jeffrey Edward Epstein, Principal, Deceased
  • Lawrence Krauss, Adjacent
Reading key
Miami HeraldSource 14reportingSarah KellenResearch Vault referenceEditorial essayargumentargument or opinion

On the morning of March 20, 2015, a car pulled up to 10,000 Waves, a Japanese-style spa resort at 3451 Hyde Park Road in Santa Fe, New Mexico. The car was arranged by Jeffrey Epstein's Zorro Development Corp staff, acting on instructions coordinated by physicist Lawrence Krauss. The passengers were Noam Chomsky and his wife Valeria. Their destination was Jeffrey Epstein's ranch in Stanley, New Mexico, southeast of Santa Fe. EFTA02082749EE, EFTA02082749 on Epstein Exposed, an alternative host for the same document

The arrangement had been worked out by email the day before.

The Arrangement

On Thursday March 19, Lawrence Krauss forwarded a message from Noam Chomsky to Jeffrey Epstein's personal Gmail account, jeevacation@gmail.com. Lesley Groff was copied. Chomsky's quoted text was 4 sentences. "All sounds fine for us. Could he pick us up around noon? We're at 10,000 Waves. Sorry about the travel disruption... Sounds fine for Sunday."

Krauss's own note to Epstein followed 3 minutes later:

"Hi.. here is the info from Noam.. I am working on whether i can take that 6 am flight on Sat.. am leaning toward doing it but will let you know later tonight. Either way, your guys can pick them up at noon, and bring them to the ranch... and I will either be with you, or see you when you land. If I am with you in Santa Fe, Amelia can meet us at the place your plane lands to take Noam and Valeria to their hotel.. If I am here, I will do that.. (once your people tell me which hanger your plane will be at..). So, will let you know tonight.. I like the idea of breakfast and a walk so assuming I have all my ducks in a row, will try and make that happen.. Thanks for everything. Lawrence"

The email sets out the logistics in a single paragraph. The Chomskys were at 10,000 Waves. Krauss was the coordinator between Chomsky and Epstein's staff. Epstein's private aviation was being staged to land in Santa Fe. A local driver named Amelia was available to move the Chomskys from the airport to a hotel if Krauss wasn't there to meet them in person. Breakfast and a walk were part of the plan. Krauss signed off with an ASU Origins Project email signature identifying him as Director. EFTA02082749EE, EFTA02082749 on Epstein Exposed, an alternative host for the same document

At the Ranch

On Friday March 20, Karen at Zorro Development Corp wrote to Brice Gordon at the ranch, including the 10,000 Waves address for the pickup. The pickup was scheduled for noon.

The record does not describe what happened at the ranch that weekend. The EFTA corpus does not contain emails narrating in-ranch activity. What the record does show is the next round of coordination, visible in a separate Larry Visoski email thread indexed later the same day.

The Departure

Larry Visoski was Jeffrey Epstein's personal pilot. On Friday March 20, Visoski was a recipient on a thread of internal Zorro coordination emails relaying Epstein's plan for the next leg of the Chomsky travel. One message in the thread summarized a just-ended conversation with Epstein:

"Ok, just spoke to JE...he says he will send Larry with Noam, Lawrence and the wife to Phoenix on Sat...then Jeffrey will depart around noon on Sunday for Phoenix himself and he WILL spend the night at the Phoenician...I would assume Monday is still on for Boston as he has promised Noam a ride to Boston...stay tuned!" EFTA00351015EE, EFTA00351015 on Epstein Exposed, an alternative host for the same document

The plan put Epstein's pilot at Santa Fe on Saturday, taking a group including Chomsky to Phoenix. Epstein himself followed on Sunday, overnighting at The Phoenician, a luxury resort in Scottsdale. On Monday, Epstein would fly Chomsky onward to Boston Logan for a Harvard engagement.

"Lawrence and the wife" in the email is the one phrase the document does not resolve. Grammatically it groups Lawrence Krauss with a wife, plausibly Krauss's. Valeria Chomsky was part of the traveling party at the pickup the previous day, and the thread does not separately account for her return travel. Whether "the wife" on the Phoenix leg refers to Valeria Chomsky, Krauss's wife, or both is not established by the document.

The same day, a separate note from Epstein's staff told Visoski that Dave Rodgers would be arriving in Albuquerque at 4 p.m. and would stay at the ranch overnight "in his usual room, the one he likes in the main living area." EFTA00351035EE, EFTA00351035 on Epstein Exposed, an alternative host for the same document

The Destination

Chomsky had a Monday commitment at Harvard. The Visoski thread identifies this as the reason for the Phoenix-to-Boston-Logan leg. The nature of the Monday engagement, whether lecture, colloquium, or private meeting, is not identified in the thread.

What the thread does establish is that Epstein used his private jet to fly Noam Chomsky from an Epstein-staged departure point (Santa Fe, via Phoenix, via Scottsdale) to an Epstein-brokered drop-off at Logan, in time for a Harvard commitment two days out from a Zorro Ranch weekend.

What the Record Does Not Show

Who else was at Zorro Ranch that weekend. Whether the Chomsky stay was a single overnight or extended. What was discussed during the breakfast and the walk Krauss had hoped to arrange. Whether Krauss made his 6 a.m. Saturday flight. Who "Amelia" is. Whether "the wife" on the Phoenix leg was Krauss's wife, Valeria Chomsky, or both. None of these is resolved by the 3 indexed EFTAs in the thread.

Several Items Remain Open

Amelia's identity. Krauss's Saturday morning flight itinerary. The nature of Chomsky's Monday Harvard engagement. Dave Rodgers's role at Zorro Ranch, staff or guest. Any post-weekend correspondence between Chomsky or Krauss and Epstein referring to what occurred at the ranch. The EFTA corpus holds additional Chomsky-Epstein correspondence from October 2015 onward, documented in The Trust and Co-Drafting a Defense under Investigation 03; a full retrieval is the next step.

Documentary artifact

The 48-hour itinerary, interactive

4 events.

Santa Fe to Zorro Ranch to Harvard

Reconstructed from three indexed emails: the Krauss–Epstein coordination thread the day before, the pickup at 10,000 Waves, and the pilot’s coordination email for the outbound flight.

Krauss’s accompanying note lays out the logistics in a single paragraph: Zorro Development Corp staff pick the Chomskys up at the spa at noon, bring them to the ranch. Epstein’s private plane will land in Santa Fe. A local driver named Amelia can move them to a hotel if Krauss isn’t there in person. Breakfast and a walk discussed.

Source, tier 1.EFTA02082749, at justice.govEE, EFTA02082749 on Epstein Exposed, an alternative host for the same document

The spa is a 35-minute drive from Zorro Ranch in Stanley, NM. The car was arranged by Epstein staff acting on Krauss’s instructions the previous day.

Source, tier 1.EFTA02082749, at justice.govEE, EFTA02082749 on Epstein Exposed, an alternative host for the same document

The corpus establishes arrival and departure but not what happened during the stay. The open question — what was discussed, who else was present — is flagged in the article.

The outbound is staged to get Chomsky to Harvard for a Monday engagement. Epstein’s personal aviation, Epstein’s pilot, Epstein’s coordination. Valeria’s onward movement is handled separately per the Krauss email.

Source, tier 1.EFTA00351015, at justice.govEE, EFTA00351015 on Epstein Exposed, an alternative host for the same document